Buy or Rent? · Methodology

How the calculation works

Compare household net wealth under matched buying and renting scenarios over a user-selected horizon.

Return to calculator

Included

  • Mortgage amortisation
  • Deposit and transaction costs
  • Maintenance, service charges and selling costs
  • Rent and property-price changes
  • Matched starting capital and monthly cost differences

Outside this method

  • A recommendation to buy or rent
  • Affordability or mortgage eligibility
  • The personal value of security and flexibility
  • Automatic tax relief and surcharge eligibility
  • Renovation, moving and insurance costs unless entered

Calculation

Core formulas

Property value

Vₜ = purchase price × (1 + property change)^t

The property-price assumption may be positive or negative.

Buying wealth

Sale value − selling costs − mortgage balance + buyer investments

The model assumes a hypothetical sale at the horizon.

Renting wealth

Invested starting capital + invested monthly differences

The renter begins with the deposit, tax and buying costs that were not spent.

Timing convention

When cash flows occur

The model compares monthly housing cash flows, invests the saving available to the cheaper option and reports annual net-wealth positions after a hypothetical sale.

Limitations

What the result cannot establish

  • Small assumption changes can move the crossover substantially.
  • Comparable homes may still differ in quality or location.
  • Mortgage rates after a product period may change.
  • Tax bands, reliefs and surcharges must be verified with the relevant authority.

Reference tests

Numerical checks

CaseInputsExpected result
Matched capital£50,000 deposit; £9,000 tax and costsRenter begins with £59,000 invested

Evidence

Sources